why homestuck is problematic why homestuck is problematic

The [Online Poisoned] often even joke with self awareness about their bad internet habits, but [they] just keep doing it, Hussie said. And thats just me. Pyscholonials doesnt give in to hopelessness. but the stance that critical enjoyment is impossible because of those aspects that don't look good today is pretty flawed. Like who? I wish more people could tell the difference between art and the artist. Thats no way to handle an issue like this. Constantly seeking out fetishistic situations and sexualizing characters in a fantasy story as well reading straight up bullshit from in-between the lines. Its a prime example of how even years after Homestuck and Hiveswap were completed the distance Hussie keeps between himself and his fandom doesnt keep his work from spiraling out into controversy. In both the SFW and NSFW route, there was no mention of him being trans. My praise of Homestucks music is really part of another thing I like about the comic. So, Hussie himself condradicted well, himself. But then, homosexuality in a society where bisexuality is the norm is kind of a different thing. hating her or not hating her and liking her as a character and oh my god can we please stop talking about Vriska). Eventually, she goes on to write a widely read manifesto; taking the reins of a militant revolutionary group that wears goth clown makeup. The alive version of this character is cute, but mostly useless. Albeit, important, weighty fanfiction elevated by the very fact they exist on homestuck.com and not on myI mean someonesGoogle Docs account locked away somewhere, but fanfiction nonetheless. there are pedophilic implications between Chahut who is confirmed to be basically an adult, soon to be taken off the planet and Amisia, a literal child, these were done by the same artist. Yo! Something went wrong. We did investigate it. "Queer Eye" star Karamo Brown recently told INSIDER that he thinks the beloved film about a gay relationship, " Call Me by Your Name ," is "problematic as f---." When I said "Hussie created them that way for a reason", this doesn't mean "Hussie agrees with literally every awful thing in Homestuck" despite what some people seem to think that's what I'm saying. The solid sales performance also lifted the food retailer's profit margins. There are pages that break the style of the website, pages that change the CSS are common, and there are pages that change their formatting to fit different content. Conveniently, two EMBEDDED HYPERLINKS have been placed within your line of sight, each fitted with an ATTRACTIVE THUMBNAIL to guide your ravenous eyes in their general vicinity. Wait, not having a shirt on is sexual now? WebPhillip Faraone/Getty Images. What the actual fuck are you talking about? On Twitter, creatives, journalists, and anyone with a modest following agonize over what people think they know about them online, and trolls regularly obsess over personal information around topics like mental health. Homestuck is also filled with blind jokes. A member of fandom may have a good attitude for a while, but since their involvement is predicated on obsession or very strongly held feelings, that positive attitude can turn on a dime, and it can take very little to trigger extreme negativity. If I release a book full of just Nazi shit but end it by saying "BTW these aren't my views I was writing as a character lol" I can't use that to cover my ass for writing a book full of Nazi shit. Like, I didnt even mention how many of these fuckers die along the way. And thats always something worth giving credit for, in my book. And then the four original kids make their game unplayable so they reset their entire universe so they can have a chance at winning. Even considering the medium of the text itself, its a remarkably online object. The proposal, which was passed 6 to 1 by the St. Paul City council, will have to be approved by the state legislature. This applies to the treatment of Mituna, who due to the overexertion of his psychic powers received brain damage that altered his personality. (not sure on the proper wording for this, if theres better wording let me know and ill change it) As a result of his accident, he is constantly babyed or harassed by other characters. From a human perspective, she's an unmistakably gay character. Every bit of it is there in order to prepare the troll kids for the game. It would not be possible because the investment we'd have to make would be significant and the return shaky, because there is such a burgeoning fan market for hand-made horns. All of them are real. Wo Long: Fallen Dynasty is the latest product to feel the review bomb burn. Andrew Hussie! If Im Hussie, I use the epilogues to tie up lose ends and put the story to rest, not start this whole other tangent about what canon really means and how all your favorite characters are actually awful people. Delorosas constant rape was considered unapologetically trashy romance and porn. #homestuck . Hussie saying that Kanaya's lesbianism is considered a fetish in troll society isn't Hussie saying that he considers lesbianism a fetish. Perhaps the epilogues are an attempt to have the reader live a moment in the life of Andrew Hussie. he makes people uncomfortable? We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our site, show personalized content and targeted ads, analyze site traffic, and understand where our audiences come from. Some intentional, some not. How can any story even get written then? She is secure in who she is, complete with her disability, without the desire to be fixed or normal. Despite this small, impressive moment, Homestuck is, overall, extremely ableist and disrespectful toward its disabled characters, and real persons with disabilities. The Homestuck following was (and is in many ways still) very involved with the project. Enjoying or creating 'problematic' media does not equate to endorsement. Point 1: Homestuck is 'problematic' in the way that many people are beginning to dislike. The impressive thing is, these couldve easily just been throw-away, cheap, forced, gags. But Homestuck wouldnt be Homestuck if not for Hussies tendency to add more when in doubt, so here we are. He is, by my estimation, the most interesting part of either epilogue, anyway. There are these four kids: John, Rose, Dave, and Jade. But the Song of Ice and Fire series is twice as long by wordcount, and that's not even finished. Dogfighting is a type of blood sport in which dogs are forced to fight one another for the entertainment and/or profit of spectators. If so, then there's nothing "wrong" with that, because they had no way of knowing they are related. A federal prison will be our emerald city. Quite a bit of it, has, unfortunately landed on rachel, who if I recall correctly, is in charge of a lot of the business decisions, or at least enforcing them. You know where else that happens? He didnt complete a draft until just a day before the first Black Lives Matter protests prompted by the murder of George Floyd at the hands of police officers in Minneapolis, Minnesota. The figure of revolution in the eyes of Hussies story is in fact, an influencer. Dividend Yield. Her Imperious Condescension is one of the most notable victims of hussies blatant racism. Its also an allegory for what Im doing presently with Psycholonials. The fact that Andrew Hussies Homestuck is terrible is an immutable fact I am stating for the record. N/A. This Mo Black guy seems to know what hes talking about, you think. I don't really care and didn't know about this before I skimmed this but you seriously didn't notice Meenah and HIC talked stereotypically black? And then, on Earth, sometime in the far future, these immortal snake alien things give birth to another alien who will eventually become the Lord English and he plays the game too. This doesn't excuse every instance, but Homestuck generally invites its readers to think critically about what's being said. A cryptid leader leaves a major vacuum of content, direction, messaging, personal information, all the stuff a frenzied cultist craves. Still, Hussie doesnt think every aspect of fandom is completely horrible. Some forms like writing fanfiction or creating fan art are a positive, fun activity. Sure, I guess. Jake sees Jane and asks her if she is alright, and Jane responds by saying: "I FEEL SO CAUCASIAN". Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Not every country has black stereotypes that are the same. To beat the game, they have to interact with the game worlds characters, and with a disgruntled group of internet trolls. I mean it is a book, so it technically is porn? Dirk uses his position as the author to berate characters he doesnt like. I expected good arguments and I see the same one used 3 times in a row. Or like how this first conversation between John and Terezi is way different knowing John spends his dying breaths bleeding out, poisoned, hate-fucking Terezi in the back of his dads Sedan. And he called himself on it too. While weve seen characters manipulate time before, Lord Englishs control over all of time in all of its forms is so absolute, his presence in the narrative is already guaranteed. The player is driven to suicide due to a callout post from cirava after they accuse the player of copying them, Theres a legit slave owner character that the fandom insists on defending no matter what. 36.87%. At its peak, the comic entertained roughly 600,000 readers a day, and inspired one of the most robust cult followings of a generation fans filled convention floors with cosplays of the characters and filled online forums and websites like Tumblr full of fan art. Can't say I ever noticed. Are you sure you aren't the one doing stereotypes here? What am I reading here? He needs everything to be relevant, and if a few character motivations and arcs need to get bent out of shape for that to happen, so be it. It makes the story feel cyclical in a good way. Accusations of certain characters beings Mary Sues. So its not that Im saying fandom is all bad, instead Id just say that the appearance of anything positive about fandom should be treated with suspicion, and as if it could become destructive at any moment for any reason. To feel what its like to be faced with a behemoth of a story and to be forced to choose: Meat or Candy, one path or the other. OK, but how is that racist? I know there are more, I'll update this list when I remember them. As your cursor (or thumb) toggles feverishly between the two links, a third option beckons. "Babyed or harassed"? While many people inside the Homestuck fandom thought this was an excellent and humorous reward (especially considering they got all the other rewards below it as well) people outside of the comic fandom didn't get the joke and thought it was an example of Hussie being and egomanical jerk. As for Karkat using "autistic" as an insult did he really? We were weirdly concerned with fundamental narrative principles at the time, more so than little kids had any right to be. I welcome it. (As he puts it, its about the things its about.) The story presents a modern path to revolution in which the catalyst for the overthrow of an imperialist system is not the military strongmen of old, but a young woman with social media savvy. Which is a lesson Jake needed to learn in the comic more generally, to be fair, but not while hes an abuse victim. I will just go ahead and read through the Google Docs about Hussie being terrible and comment every time I have something to say. The largest, most active Homestuck community. Technically, a lack of masking is a presentation issue a sign that a theater no longer cares but it can lead to projection problems, too. What is the cost? And then John implies that its maybe Jakes fault for letting it get as bad as it did? This is just a single example of how bootleg items (because yes, even if they're being made with love and sold with respect for the original creator, they are bootleg items) can directly influence a small business' decisions and bottom line. He forces Rose to consent to being kidnapped, then makes her wife, Kanaya, blame herself for it all. Media analysis, fiction, and the art of writing the perfect story. Why? They obviously "matured" when dead. So, you are saying I can't write about people who are not me? Chances are Hussie changed it in part because he wasn't really feeling the joke in the first place. Still, he said that the text works as a thematic followup to his entire experience with building a fandom. And in this one Mituna himself just kind of sexually harrasses Meenah. Dirk is Homestucks ultimate villain. EVERYONE IS DEAD). And then that ability comes in handy when the eight kids and the original players lose the game again. Dividend Yield. Some of my other favorites among Homestucks ten main albums and many more side-releases include Unite Synchronization, Derse Dreamers, I Dont Want to Miss A Thing, At the Price of Oblivion, and Showtime. As of now, recordings of the content exist on YouTube and are embedded where the Flash animations used to be, but take it from me when I say its really not the same. WebThis process, known as review-bombing, has been used for both good and bad causes. Then theres this: i consider the kids a-racial. The paradoxes are explained via a Universe space that allows them to be such. WebRead MS Paint Adventures. The few legitimate criticisms that arent nitpicks or blind virtue signaling arent even all that damning. Im not sure how much there is thats truly positive about those things, but there is plenty which is negative. As he comes to better understand and accept himself for who he is, the homophobia fades from his vocabulary, he opens up to people, and allows more of his vulnerabilities to show though. The SFW hes the stereotype of a transman. Obviously, this sort of mockery is considered ableist. The story feels like a retelling of the hell-year that was 2020, but Hussie started drafting the story back when everyone was just starting to be stuck inside for the first time. Music is so integral to the experience of Homestuck Id argue the story doesnt work without it. About 8,000 pages. Umm no. When I read that, I remember scoffing. But how much is that purpose worth? But it's also a prime example of the hidden insolvency that exists across much of the banking sector. Copyright issues; unlike many, more mainstream content producers who kind of give convention artists alleys the big shrugaroo, Hussie, as a small buisness owner, is very strict about people selling fanmade Homestuck content. With some of the claims, I doubt the author has even read homestuck, because they are clearly missing the context of the scenes. From $23.00 Dance Shirt (White) *LAST CHANCE* Brunetto-4%. But Homestuck isn't about fan inclusion for the sake of happy-fun-creating together, it's about WHY we might want to do that and a host of other things. I feel like you had "better" things to say than I did. Oh yeah also you link to ipgd's post with Cool Dude and Stoner Lou, which, for context, is a direct parody of Shredded Moose--you really need that context to understand CDASL. With the source of his partial-paralysis being Vriska, he is tormented by her and others on occasion for his disability. Possibly in a bid to avoid pulpiting to any fans, or even me the writer, he said he doesnt think his story is telling each and every person to cut themselves off. And then theres genocide. But I want it to be more than an audio FAQ, I want it to be a bit of pseudo-documentary on the fandom as well. Due to fans arguing over the race of characters Hussie put in a joke in which one of the characters (jane) says "I feel so caucasion" when she's in trickster mode. Theres the aforementioned not-finishing-the-story-ness I talked about earlier. When I logged in every post I saw on the issue was complaining about how more people were complaining about people complaining about the Caucasian thing than there were people complaining about the Caucasian thing. Except, https://www.homestuck.com/story/386 has this to say: EB: that's fine, you are entitled to your opinion, i am just saying that being a white guy who is a rapper with a ventriloquist doll is not cool by any stretch of the imagination or by any definition of word cool, ironic or otherwise. The fact that Homestuck isn't an anime makes them unpopular at anime conventions, despite things like video game and doctor who costumes being accepted in part because of their large numbers. Oops. We apologize for this inconvenience, & our engineers are working diligently to get this resolved ASAP. Commedia Doll'Arte Wo Long: Fallen Dynasty is the latest product to feel the review bomb burn. Id Id tell you more about them, but the comic doesnt at all bother to develop this cool idea in the slightest. Question: Hey hiveswap team and @skullmandible, confirm Lanque as a trans boy yes/no? Shraddha Walkar, Nikki Yadav: Why the coverage of crimes against women is problematic; Shraddha Walkar, Nikki Yadav: Why the coverage of crimes against women is problematic When such murders are headlined with the term live-in, the choice of the victim to cohabitate with a partner takes precedence over the criminal act of the offender The language is deeply rooted in the now, and leans into the internet vernacular with words like simp, e-girls, reply guys, and cringe. At one point, one of the protagonists moves from being a fan, to dating a member of the popular K-pop group BTS (which also happens to be one of the biggest, most influential fandoms of the moment). Alternia, at least at first, is a dark joke about our real-world society. Energy transfers to keep her alive are sexual now, I guess You get assaulted by a lot of trolls. There are some aspects of Homestuck that deserve a deeper analysis and deconstruction than I can give here. ), heres an approximation of just how insane that is: new writers are advised that the first book the try to publish should be around 6070 thousand words. If it is morally wrong, I want explanations.). Theres also the fact that the epilogues have no qualms about crushing aspects of the story the reader may have enjoyed. Fans still regularly obsess over questions and details of Hussies life and work. Yes it is. Maybe they exist in a doomed timeline, or as a ghost, or in an offshoot reality that got retconned and is no longer relevant. We are currently experiencing a system-wide issue with a delay on all activations. To start, www.stopableism.org is a great resource for learning more about what ableism actually is. It spent its last moments introducing characters and mechanics only to turn around and not explain jack. By the end of both epilogues, Rose, Dave, and Dirk ascend to their Ultimate Selves. But, there is still no ETA for everything to work normally again. Agreed. Wi-Fi 6E is the latest Wi-Fi technology that provides faster speeds, lower latency, and improved overall network performance. To me, black is just a color. No Disney-style moral to repeat to your children. The self-ingratiating, self-referential, over-indulgent drivel that poured onto the page? But I strongly recommend it! Dedicated fans even created a browser extension that notified you the moment new Homestuck content went up. I've been dealing with this stuff for years--just this very small, specific subset of the law in question--and I still ask our legal counsel for clarification or confirmation fairly often, because it's not always straightforward. Anyone who presides over something popular is forced to play the role of an informal cult leader, which is what it felt like throughout most of Homestucks run, and even well beyond. He said, Some online personalities will revel in that role, and actually start behaving like a true cult leader. At times it is as if the text is saying that since Tavros is not normal because of his disability, he is not normal to society in general, as well. People have clamored for us to produce high quality cosplay-ready horns for years, ever since I began working at WP. People actually pull a bigger fit about the fact that it was retconed than they ever did over the original joke. Who is this detective? Granted, this panel also depicts the fact that Terezi uses a cane to walk around, which is realistichowever, we rarely ever it in regular interactions with her. The very same iteration of Vriska that is also 13. And then theres this game in the mail. And then there are all the people who cant shroud themselves in secrecy. If you are talking about, Karkat: hey asshole, stop playing games for girls, then I see it differently from you. If a character uses a slur, the fault falls onto the character, not on the author (at least in my eyes). Yet hes made multiple, incredibly racist characters that are heavily based on disgusting caricatures and stereotypes. And then theres this punch-card based, bit-wise inventory system that they exploit to make whatever they want in the game. Taken from this page , here is a brief overview of ableism, how it impacts persons with disabilities, and its negative role in society. Troll Jewish would have been a great addition! true wait, what? And then the four kids and their parents, Jane, Roxy, Dirk, and Jake, swap places, so the new kids are their parents and the parents are their kids, but the original four leave before theyre erased from existence and meet up with the original players from that other universe. WebBut, there is still no ETA for everything to work normally again. And then theres this gang war between these black alien mobsters, the Midnight Crew, and a time gang, the Felt, whos boss, Lord English is destined to destroy the multiverse. As both of the characters are canonically gay many people consider it erasing their sexuality to put them in heterosexual pairings in fanfic. What video games and movies dont depict correctly is the insane recoil automatic fire causes. (But please, don't jsut say that "it's morally wrong" and then not explain how. I can come to my own conclusions. Remember how Lanque is trans?