When comparing Aeneas and Odysseus from the Aeneid and The Odyssey, respectively, Odysseus is more successful at utilizing the components of the epic because his method is more imaginative and innovative. This is a visual aid that helps you understand which characteristics your subjects share, and which ones are exclusive. Scholars estimate he was born as early as 700 B.C. Creusa is lost and killed as her family attempts to flee the city, but tells Aeneas he will find a new wife at his new home. However, Odysseus and Achilles are more contrasting than they are similar. A Greek king who wed Helen and made a pact with her other suitors to fight anyone who tried to steal her. Aeneas helps his people and encourages them in the burial rites for Misenus. He realizes that as leader of his people, he must fight Turnus so he can provide his people with a new city they can call their own. He is a strong, unselfish leader because he has the strength to place his people;s emotions above his to meet their needs. on 50-99 accounts. Both men exemplified courage, perseverance and leadership. He is willing to die to fulfill his purpose. Theyre also a common assignment for college essays since they show the instructor how well you grasp both subjects. He and Aeneas both have epic adventures. 3521. QUESTION: Compare/contrast the Greek culture hero revealed in the Iliad and the Odyssey and the Hebrew culture hero developed in the Old Testament readings in our text. We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. In the first paragraph after the introduction, the author talks only about Ahab from, , but in the next paragraph talks only about the narrator from. Copyright 2023 Leaf Group Ltd. / Leaf Group Education, Explore state by state cost analysis of US colleges in an interactive article, Hope College: Introduction to Virgil, "The Aeneid", Virginia Tech: The Passions of Achilles and Aeneas: Translating Greece Into Rome. In this case, all the soldiers obey. You'll also receive an email with the link. Try Grammarly now and see how your writing improves. Save over 50% with a SparkNotes PLUS Annual Plan! A joke to your enemies and an embarrassment to yourself (Book 3. If you want to learn more about this process, read our comprehensive guide on essay writing, which better explains the details. In the first paragraph after the introduction, the author talks only about Ahab from Moby Dick, but in the next paragraph talks only about the narrator from The Raven. Compare And Contrast The Aeneid And The Odyssey. When Pentheus goes to Mount Cithaeron, he is compared to a. What are the fundamental differences between how the heroes view themselves, their people, and their respective quests? Acknowledgments Proem: Postmodernism (Again) and The Jeffersonian Vision in Steve Ericksons Arc dX are excerpted from my address at the 2005 Kyoto American Studies Summer Seminar, Heteroclite Historiography: Representations of the Past in Contemporary American Fiction, in Proceedings of the Kyoto American Studies Seminar, August . In a foreign country and sailed off with Print. 172-173 Published by:Classical Association of the Atlantic States Article Stable URL: http://www. When the Trojans reach Latium, he continues to act as a good ruler by sending gifts to Latinus and making plans for a new orderly city. Infuriated, Achilles kills the Trojan prince Hector in Book 22 and dishonorably drags his body around Troy. We help them Feel free to get in touch with us via email to: Summarystory.com provides students with professional writing and editing assistance. Aeneas gives gifts to all the participants and exhibits his savvy as a leader by saying all the right things at the right time. them cope with academic assignments such as essays, articles, term and research papers, They put others before themselves. Download. This essay was written by a fellow student. . But, Aeneas himself went first in labor, cheering his fellows on, with implements like theirs in hand (Virgils Aeneid 166). A compare-and-contrast essay analyzes two subjects by either comparing them, contrasting them, or both. org/stable/696316. Even though Polydorus advises Aeneas to leave Thrace, he first consults other leaders of the people before making a decision; he does not abuse his power. The question will be answered by first, analyzing the individual characteristics of Achilles, a merciless warrior, and Aeneas, a civilized leader, thenshow more content Paris, who is the root of it all, almost ended up with the same fate as Hector in the hands of Menelaus, the husband of Helen. Grammarly helps you write with confidence The triumvirate was a way to split the military and political power. Exercise Two At first glance, Virgil's description of Aeneas' shield in The Aeneid may just appear to be a conveyance of Roman history. Sources for the course will include greeting cards, advertisements, magazine illustrations, decorations, cookbooks and recipes, genre paintings, music, photographic documentation of parades and festivals, and . for a group? To do so, ask yourself a few questions: What are you trying to show in your compare-and-contrast essay? Neptune (Poseidon in Greek mythology) calms the storm that opens the epic and conducts Aeneas safely on the last leg of his voyage. 21 - 31. 4 Respect for the gods. This great, but self-centered warrior, is immortalized in the phrase "Achilles heel," which is a symbol of flawed weakness. Aeneas is the embodiment of Roman virtues: He is the dutiful servant of fate and of the gods, he is an exemplary leader of his people, and he is a devoted father and son. We discuss how to structure your essay and how to frame your thesis, but first, lets take a broader look at why comparison essays are so useful. The Aeneid is an epic poem written by Virgil. Paragraphs in compare-and-contrast essays can get complicated, so its crucial to have a good topic or introduction sentence for each paragraph to make the flow of ideas clear. The protagonist of TheAeneid. If the writing in your compare-and-contrast essay starts getting messy, Grammarlys writing suggestions recommend alternative phrasings to clear things up. Looking at your lists, you can then decide on the thesis. As a result, he becomes a hero and an ancestor of the Roman after a big fight between the Trojan and the Italian. Aeneas' actions during the fall of Troy help, in the mytho-historical tradition, contribute to the founding of the Roman people later. The main characters in this war and the story that comes with it (The Iliad) are Achilles the best fighter on the Greek side and Hector the Trojans best warrior. compare and contrast aeneas and hectoraiken county sc register of deeds compare and contrast aeneas and hector The Iliad Books 16-18. Achilles has one family member: his mother, Thetis. The ancient world literature is filled with epic tales of heroes and gods who go on perilous adventures to foreign lands and encounter many mythical beings along the way. Achilles showcased his stubborn side when he saw that Agamemnon had dishonored him and said that he would not fight. This method works best if you want to focus on a particular similarity or difference between your subjects, or if you want to build up to a powerful conclusion or reveal at the end. Archetypes are stories that use characters that are repeated throughout many cultures (Rice). A leader usually has people for him and against him. Beyond knowing the full process for crafting a compare-and-contrast essay, it helps to learn a few tips to ensure it shines. You discuss all the similarities between your subjects and then all the differences, or vice versa (differences first and then similarities). Luckily, Grammarly offers suggestions to. Aeneas embodies the Roman value of duty. Instead of ordering his people on what needs to be done for the funeral rights, Aeneas performs the burial for his comrades death. In our example above, the author wishes to highlight just how different the aliens of Arthur Clarke are from those of other authors, particularly H. G. Wells. So he insults Paris and provokes him to confront Menelaus. Hyperbole in Writing: Definition and Examples, Everything You Need to Know About Appendices in Writing, Chicago Manual of Style Format and Citations. A leader or a hero would never back down from his task. This act is intended to show that he is not asking for a fight. However, she was not a particularly fiery woman who stood up for herself. Thats when compare-and-contrast essays function at their best. Lavinias character is not developed in the poem; she is important only as the object of the Trojan-Latin struggle. God intervention caused one of the bloodiest wars in history, the Trojan War. Hector says these words before Achilles kill him. Aeneas is a good leader because he is not selfish with his own desires, but instead cares for the desires of his people for the new homeland. Compare and Contrast Essay The structure of the archetypal story has been used since the beginning of civilizations. Hector fights with heart. The Aeneid translated by Robert Fitzgerald. The illiad book 1 Who is the king of the Achaens Who is the best warriar Where are they making war What was the reason for this war Who were. His people are more important to him than himself. In Book III, Aeneas becomes more comfortable with his role as leader. Only this. In Book I, Cupid (Eros in Greek mythology) disguises himself as Ascanius, Aeneass son, and causes Dido to fall in love with Aeneas. Hector loves his family but continues his fate to bring glory to Troy and his family. Why in human nature is there room for both manifestations? In the foot race, Nisus trips Salius so Euryalus will win. Without the help of divine intervention though, neither hero would have met his destiny, though there were opposing gods who wanted to delay and provide hardship for the heroes along the journey. The king of the Latins, the people of what is now central Italy, around the Tiber River. They invoke fate, soldierly duty and heroism. He cares about their underworld lives. Yet "The Aeneid ends with Turnus death and no call for remorse. Contact us coursework, case studies, PowerPoint presentations, reviews, etc. The king of Troy. Hector does not express any unwillingness in being the leader of the army that defended the city of Troy, until the fated day of his death in the hands of Achilles. She is also referred to as Cytherea, after Cythera, the island where she was born and where her shrine is located. 4.6. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett, 1997. He listens to Apollo instead of Dido. Aeneas is a great leader not because he is put in difficult situations; Aeneas is a great leader because he leads and does not let his emotions show through those difficult situations. His rage is seen when he takes Hectors body and mutilates it. The epic poet's delight in naming things is always accompanied, in Homer . Virgil describes him in Book I as "father Aeneas" and "fond father, as always thoughtful of his son." [9] Throughout Book VI, Virgil reinforces that Aeneas's future is fated despite the hardships he must endure along the way. The Virtues of Augustus Compared to Aeneas' Early in the first century, around 27 B.C.E., Augustus was presented with a golden shield by the Senate of Rome (Augustus 34). In Book V of the Aeneid, the athletic games are being held. This shows his human qualities. After hearing the prophecies, Aeneas is determined to fulfill his mission despite obstacles that might hinder his progress. Andromache begs Hector not to leave. It is well that the Greeks and Trojans should be at peace, for there is no quarrel between them. The downside is that they dont describe the individual subjects as much as single-topic essays. compare and contrast aeneas and hector. 51 Comments Please sign inor registerto post comments. This selection inspires the permanent wrath of Juno against the Trojans. Therefore, though shame and anger tempted them to a pitched battle, even so they barred their gates as he commanded, and compact in towers, armed, awaited their enemy. Hektors fate is to die. SparkNotes PLUS In contrast, Aeneas' approach is more basic and practical. The first paragraph after the introduction discusses what the governments in the two books have in common, but the next paragraph explains how they differ. 2135 Words; 9 Pages; Essay on Compare and Contrast of Odysseus and Aeneas. She and her city are strong, but she becomes an unfortunate pawn of the gods in their struggle for Aeneass destiny. No matter which option you choose, you have to pay particular attention to. Even though Andromache begs him to stay, he fights knowing his death is waiting for him. He respects Aeneas's role as leader and makes every attempt to follow through with Aeneas's duties. Compare and contrast the mythological aspects of the Aeneid with those found in the Greek Iliad and Odyssey. Looking at your brainstorming lists, decide which structuring method would best get your point across: block, alternating, or similarities/differences. Cite this page as follows: "In comparing Achilles and Aeneas as a hero, explain the difference and similarities of their motivations." eNotes Editorial, 1 Aug. 2019, https://www.enotes.com . Youre nothing but trouble for your father and your city, Ascanius is like his father because when he kills one enemy, he does not speak with pride over his victory. Ascanius will become a good leader from watching his fathers leadership skills. Lets say you want to write an essay about how great renewable resources are, but you spend a lot of your time explaining how fossil fuels work. And lastly, unlike Paris, Hector does not receive any help from the gods which leads to his ultimate death. March 4, 2023, SNPLUSROCKS20 Both Achilles and Hector were from The Iliad, which is an epic story written by Homer. While Aeneas is away is Book IV, Ascanius takes charge, taking the role of his father. For example, if the teacher said not to talk while she left the room, some students would disobey. Achilles is the protagonist of Homer's epic poem "The Iliad." To emphasize this, the essay author juxtaposes the two points right next to each other in the same paragraph. This work narrates the story of Augustus by using the character, Aeneas. Solve these problems before they start by smartly choosing your subjects at the beginning. Aeneas starts the Aeneid with gifts and prayers, and he ends the Aeneid with gifts and prayers. In the Aeneid and the Odyssey, Aeneas and Odysseus both undergo a parallel journey with the ultimate purpose of returning (in Aeneas' case establishing) a home.However, throughout their journeys, the actions of the two heroes are vastly different. No one questions Aeneas in his decision making. You discuss one subject in full and then move on to the next subject. 48 Vitosha Boulevard, ground floor, 1000, Sofia, Bulgaria Bulgarian reg. Paris, who is the root of it all, almost ended up with the same fate as Hector in the hands of Menelaus, the husband of Helen. Type your requirements and I'll connect Compare-and-contrast essays have a lot in common with other essay types, but differ in many ways, tooand thats the heart of comparing and contrasting! , 1951), pp. Being a leader does not mean one is strong all the time and does not cry. 50-56). A Trojan and a personal friend of Aeneas. The World are two completely different stories, comparisons can be made between the two main characters, Aeneas and Scott Pilgrim. Aeneas is a good leader because he performs all of these acts throughout the Aeneid. 23, No. We will hear a stasimon chorus by Euripides, and we will compare a 1st-century-C.E. The river god associated with the Tiber River, where Rome will eventually be built. The god of the winds, enlisted to aid Juno in creating bad weather for the Trojans in Book I. 17, No. The best leaders are those that put others before themselves. 4.5. . Let us help you get a good grade on your paper. The lecture focuses on the role of music in the ancient Greek and Roman world. JSTOR: Classical Antiquity: Achilles' Heel, The Death of Achilles in Ancient Myth, The New York Times: Art Review: The Legacy of Homer: Triumphant Greeks from the Academy, University of Washington: Honors Program in Rome: Bernini's Sculptures in the Villa Borghese (first image), Massachusetts Institute of Technology: Troilus and Cressida (e-text), Massachusetts Institute of Technology: The Life and Death of Julius Caesar. By continuing well assume youre on board with our Achilles and Aeneas demonstrate that an epic hero will do whatever it takes to fulfill their duties while simultaneously displaying the difference between Greek and Roman Society. Aeneas also suffers in that he is not ever able to see the fruits of his labors throughout his life. A Latin leader who desires an end to the Trojan-Latin struggle. since they show the instructor how well you grasp both subjects. Save Paper; 3 Page . Get Annual Plans at a discount when you buy 2 or more! Type. When Aeneas carries Pallass body, he is filled with tears. Drafting Here you write your rough draft; this is the longest and toughest phase. Saturn (Chronos in Greek mythology) was king of Olympus until his son Jupiter overthrew him. He must give up his homeland and leave behind his love, Dido, to fulfill his destiny. He provides for his people when they find a safe harbor on the North African coast of Libya by making sure they have food to eat, and he comforts and motivates them by reminding them of their destined homeland. Comparison of Dido and Medea. Both destinies will take them from their lovers. on 2-49 accounts, Save 30% Compare-and-contrast essays follow our own. He is an unselfish leader filled with a compassionate heart: Weeping, I drew away from our old country [] (Virgils Aeneid 65). with the standard rules and best practices. He does not fight for himself; he fights for his family and Troy. The Classical Journal, Vol. Your group members can use the joining link below to redeem their group membership. Therefore, he proceeds in a selfish act and withdraws himself which shows lack of leadership towards his men. Writing, grammar, and communication tips for your inbox. He is fighting for his wife, Andromache, to free her life of slavery. The downside is that they dont describe the individual subjects as much as single-topic essays. The fact that Aeneas has ultimate power does not mean he abuses it. His spirit is still with his people. ?>. Aeneas has to leave his men to cry over the loss of eager Orantes and Amycus. A compare-and-contrast essay is a style of essay that points out the similarities and differences between two or more subjects. (Version 6) * concise introductions to the plays and other works * images of how . These two epic heroes share similar fates, yet are different in personality. The role of the good father and son is evident in Aeneas's character. Meanwhile, in Act One, scene two of Julius Caesar, Cassius in speaks warmly of "Aeneas, our great ancestor.". His journey was terrible and in the end, all his men were slain and he alone returned to Ithaca. More specifically, what are the differences and similarities between Aeneas and Achilles or Aeneas and Hector? Compare And Contrast Zinn And Columbus On The Indians. Odysseus is patient throughout his journey and it is a blessing that he is because he does not have the gods' favor and his men are obstinate. Compare and Contrast: Aneas and Turnus. The oldest example of an archetype is The Epic of Gilgamesh. Leaders and heroes are sometimes mistaken for superheroes that are exempt from tragic situations. In contrast, Mezentius relies on himself. Aeneas proves he is a good leader by caring about his people who have died. As another option, you can break paragraphs up by a specific topic and issue, and in each paragraph discuss both or all subjects. Unlike Turnus, Aneas is able to place his beliefs in the fated . Aeneas is meant to reflect the ideals of Augustan Rome: contrasting with the inflated ego and borderline hubris of Achilles . Aeneas has a leadership ability that enforces others to act as a leader. 589 Words3 Pages. Many of the people balk at this scene because of the unfairness. He is a fearsome warrior and a leader able to motivate his men in the face of adversity, but also a man capable of great compassion and sorrow. jstor. When Paris took Helen, the pact was invoked and the Trojan War began. Essentially, you have three options: No matter which option you choose, you have to pay particular attention to topic sentences. First things first: You need to choose which subjects youre comparing. The son of Achilles. Good leaders listen to the opinions of others instead of quickly making a decision. Virgil shows in the Aeneid that Aeneas absence in Book IX does not affect his role as a good leader. No one knows when the blind poet Homer lived. Dr. Stephen Bay. Achilles continued to follow this pattern throughout the story and was full of vengeance. $24.99 Virgil points out Aeneas giving gifts to the gods at the beginning of the Aeneid: As I made offering to Diones daughter, my divine mother, and to other gods who give protection to a work begun [] (Virgils Aeneid 66). The reader can picture swift-footed Achilles on the heels of Hektor, tamer of horses. While the linked guide goes into more detail, in a nutshell, your compare-and-contrast essay should follow a simple format of beginning, middle, and end: where you explain your thesis or what your essay will discuss, where you actually list the similarities and differences of your subjects; the largest section, where you wrap up and summarize your points, The introduction, usually one or two paragraphs, should include a thesis statement to show the reader what to expect for the rest of your essay. As the Romans adopted the Gods, philosophy and culture of the ancient Greeks into their civilization, using the best the ancient world had to offer and adapting it to justify their own ends as keepers of a worldwide empire, so did Virgil adopt Homer's style and themes into his own work. 34-42 Published by:Cambridge University Presson behalf ofThe Classical Association Article Stable URL: http://www. Angry with Greek general Agamemnon, he forsakes battle, leaving his best friend Patroclus to be killed in his place. Research Article. In this guide, we explain how to write a compare-and-contrast essay, including some advanced tips and examples. Essay on Compare and Contrast of Odysseus and Aeneas. Although both epics end with a heros death, in "The Iliad Achilles is begged to return Hectors desecrated corpse to his father, Priam, for a proper funeral rite. Finally, you want to make sure you corrected all the spelling and grammatical mistakes in your draft. 6 (Mar. dissertations, coursework, case studies, PowerPoint presentations, reviews, etc. and any corresponding bookmarks? . If they acted out of selfishness, they would have fought back as they wished to have done. Paris at last agrees to fight Menelaus, proclaiming that the duel will decide peace between Achaeans and Trojans. She is also a patron of Carthage and knows that Aeneass Roman descendants are destined to destroy Carthage. The fact that his crowd remains quiet shows that his people trust him and obey his ruling. Your subscription will continue automatically once the free trial period is over. We discuss, Lets say you want to write an essay about how great renewable resources are, but you spend a lot of your time explaining how fossil fuels work. In the Aeneid, Virgil shows that nothing blinds his sense of duty. This is the most important scene to showing how great a leader Aeneas is because his people respect his orders without him being there to remind them. A Comparison of Aeneas, Achilles, and Odysseus 2nd essay of the semester (2 are required). ?>, Order original essay sample specially for your assignment needs, Comparison: Hector in Iliad vs. Hector in Troy, The Aeneid of Greece by Virgil The Aeneid, Compare and Contrast of Hector and Achilles, A Sympathetic Antonio in Hector Tobar's The Tattooed Soldier, Fate and Destiny in the Aeneid and the Odyssey, get custom A person can become a good leader by observing a good leader: It is quite in character for Andromache in Book 3 of the Aeneid and Iapyx in Book 12 to link Hector and Aeneas together as models of manly virtue for young Ascanius (Spaeth 278). Aeneas and Hektor have the heart of leadership. A good leader takes care of his fellow comrades. In Book III, Aeneas's paternal responsibilities are expanded to include his son, the Trojans in his care, and the future of the Roman race. The block method is usually divided into paragraphs: a paragraph about one subject and then a new paragraph about another subject. Angered by the mistreatment of Hector's body, Apollo assists Paris, who is the least of all Trojan fighters, as he shoots a poisoned arrow into Achilles' mortal heel. The purpose of writing a comparison or contrast essay is not to state the obvious but rather to illuminate subtle differences or unexpected similarities between two subjects. (Virgils Aeneid 260) Aeneas unselfishness leads to the peoples unselfishness. Achilles -- Great but Selfish Achilles is the protagonist of Homer's epic poem "The Iliad." We use cookies to create the best experience for you. He wants no part in the Trojan War and refuses to fight until his young companion, Patroclus, is killed by Hector. Hector does not express any unwillingness in being the leader of the army that defended the city of Troy, until the fated day of his death in the hands of Achilles. 2 Curing the French Disease. This handout will help you first to determine whether a particular assignment is asking for comparison/contrast and then to generate a list of similarities and differences, decide which similarities and differences to focus on, and organize your paper so that it will be clear and effective. Aeneas leaves Dido for his people and the new Troy. Where the Iliad illuminates both the valor and peril inherent in war, Virgils Aeneid does so with a clear political purpose. Like Homers famous epics, the Iliad and Odyssey, Virgils. Let me start this paper with an introduction to what an epic poem is, since Virgils Aeneid and Homers Iliad are both epic poem.. With the first draft finished, you can more easily identify any areas that need to be fixed, revised, or rewritten from scratch. Compare and contrast the first six books of Vergil's Aeneid with Homer's Odyssey. While the gods often struggle against one another in battles of will, Jupiters will reigns supreme and becomes identified with the more impersonal force of fate. However, he begins his own rescue efforts afterward, carrying his aged father Anchises on his shoulders out of battle and leading other Trojans to safety. Hector was interested in other people and was a loving person who cared for his wife, children and brother. But when youre in the heat of a writing session, it can be difficultand distractingto stop and evaluate your work for clarity. In most cases, people would act against their leader if he were not present. SparkNotes Plus subscription is $4.99/month or $24.99/year as selected above. The similarities between Achilles and Hector is that both lived in the present moment and both wanted to achieve glory in order to be the hero that their homeland needed, while the differences include Achilles being stubborn and angry while Hector was prideful, yet cowardly and impulsive. He demonstrates appropriate pietas devotion to one's family, country, and mission. Near the end of both wars, each hero must face and kill a final foe: as Achilles kills Hector, the bravest of the Trojan army, Aeneas kills the hero of the Latins, Turnus. Evaluate the following algebraic expression using the given values for the variables 1. One of the Furies, or deities who avenge sins, sent by Juno in Book VII to incite the Latin people to war against the Trojans. Aeneas realizes his future homeland is more important than his relationship with Dido.